My dad was a milkman who knew more about union halls than investment strategies, And then he died before I learned to add, much less multiply, so it didn't matter anyway. My mom knew how to stock a pantry and bond with her kids. But she only invested in flour and yeast for the inordinately large amounts of bread she baked.
I didn't listen to my uncle, the one person in my blue-collar family who knew anything about investing. It wasn't because he was wrong. He was just the most unpleasant man I ever met (and, I've come to believe, he was just plain nuts).
I learned everything I know about the markets from trial and error, barroom conversations, and a desire to avoid that sinking feeling you get when you open the quarterly statement from a misguided investment.
If I knew then what I know now, I'd have more money and less stuff. I'd have invested in companies -- stocks, bonds, and mutual funds -- instead of the things they made... betamax, Mi, niDiscs, LaserDiscs, recordable DVD players, and other so-called next big things. I acquired a lot of stuff, and tossed most of it before it gained value as an oddity.
But then I had kids. And once you have kids, two things happen: You discover investing is a wonderful thing because it reduces the money you're likely to spend on the cheaply made toys that drive you crazy. You also spend a great deal of time thinking of ways to teach your children all the things you never knew, in the hope of sparing them some of your mistakes.
So here's what I'd like my kids to know about investing.
Don't be afraid.
You date people you'll be embarrassed to acknowledge in five years, risk a cold (or worse) playing beer pong with strangers, and think it's fun to skydive, bungee jump, or repel off a bridge at 3 a.m. So what do you have to fear from the stock market? You have decades until retirement, little or no responsibility, and more disposable income than you'll probably have in years. So go for it!
Embrace what you love.
Youth, an old man complains in It's a Wonderful Life, is wasted on the young. And here's why: You have a unique perspective on products and services that most investors, who are old by comparison, understand only through market research. So when you start thinking about investing, start thinking about the things you do, the places you go, and the clothes and accessories you wear. What's new? What's interesting? What looks to be something everyone wants? Just make a list. Then find out which ones are made by publicly traded companies, and you'll be on your way to your first investments.
Dare to compare.
Take those five or six public companies on your list and ask yourself a simple question: Which one (or two or three) has the greatest potential to generate a return so you can 1) travel; 2) play; 3) zone out; or 4) avoid getting a part-time job? When you look at the potential benefit, you won't feel as daunted when I tell you to spend a few hours checking out any of the companies on your shortlist.
Get under the hood.
To research a company, you have to know what to look for. So do a little digging around. Our Guide to Investment Metrics is a good place to start. Once you understand what to look for, then look up the statistics for each company. It's not hard. In fact, WolframAlpha makes it as easy as entering the name of a company or its stock symbol and hitting "submit." You'll get fundamentals, stock history, even an understanding of whether analysts think it's a good time to buy the company's stock.
Size doesn't matter.
Say you just have $50. Is it too little to invest? Not necessarily. Some companies offer Dividend Reinvestment Plans (DRPs) or Direct Stock Purchase Plans (DSPs), which allow you to bypass paying the broker's commission and buy stock directly from the issuing companies or their agents. Not all companies offer them. But more than 1,000 do, including most major blue chip stocks. If that's not an option, then look into a discount brokerage account. Some offer first-time bonuses of $50 or more, which will cover the $10 or so you'll have to pay in commission.
Diversity is good.
If you have enough to invest in more than one company, then spread your wealth around. Pick several companies from various sectors: technology, apparel, food and beverages, whatever. You don't want to put all your money in one industry, no matter how much you love it.
Set a target.
Once you narrow your choices, look at the stock prices. Say a share is selling for $10. Decide -- before you buy -- when you'll sell it. There are all kinds of technical tools you can use to set a sell price. (See Understanding Stops, Targets & Total Risk.) But you can always start with something simple: Promise yourself you'll sell when the share price increases by a certain amount, 25% or 50%, perhaps. Just pick a target, and then stick with it. Because remember: Even great products peak. The goal is to get out before they fall.
Have fun.
Do I have to remind you that you're young? Worried you might screw up? So what. You'll recover. You'll learn. You'll gain insight and experience. The market goes up and down, and eventually, just when you're convinced it won't, back up again. You'll make money over time. But the market is like the lottery. You have to be in it to win it.
Excellent point Tenacious. We have to expose our kids to the same ups and downs of investing that we already expose them to in other aspects of their lives.
We encourage kids to play sports, pick up an musical instrument, perfect their creative talents. Then we balk at encouraging them to invest. Well, let's be realistic. Some kids have their egos bruised on the baseball field, and they get over it. So what's the big deal if they invest their birthday money in a stock that sputters? They may feel annoyed, but it's not the end of the world. We just have to teach them its ok to try, and encourage the ones who have an aptitude to stick with it.
I'm revisiting this post after a couple of days away and I think it is incredible--and incredibly wonderful--to see the amount of interest it has generated. Speaks well for us as interested "financial parents," I would say!
As the one who originally mentioned the concept of paper portfolios, I see that there are a number of folks who are intrigued by the idea, either like #erierunner from personal experience or because it sounds like a great way for a young investor to crawl before (s)he walks. Then there are those who feel that nothing can really be learned without plunging in, kind of the "take off the training wheels and risk a skinned knee" school of learning.
My opinion is that the two aren't necessarily mutually exclusive. I think excellent--and different--lessons can be learned from both, perhaps even at the same time. A paper portfolio provides a great conceptual introduction and provides for the study of lots of different types of stocks and, it goes without saying, that it provides for diversification that isn't possible with buying just one.
It also allows for a little sector research before a young investor needs to feel pressured to choose the ONE and ONLY first stock ever. Because remember--if that first purchase is a LOSER, it will be ALL YOUR FAULT, and it will be a cold day in Hell before (s)he will feel like betting the clothing allowance on another investment purchase!
On the other hand, at some point life does need to be lived without a safety net, and if there is an upside to be had, it's pretty fun to have it be an actual profit, not just a plus column on a spreadsheet.
Bottom line, as with so many parent/child decisions, I think it depends on the personality, interest level and maturity of your particular kid, and it's nice to have a number of lures in the tackle box to reel them in.
And you never know...I went to business school with a guy who swore on a stack of Bibles that he bought his first car as a teenager with his profits from trading frozen orange juice futures!
While an investor may behavedifferently with a mock portfolio versus real life money it is a tool for learning. We all drove a car in drivers Ed differently than we do in the real world but it still helped us all get our license. A mock portfolio can help and individual get over their fear of investing and help them develop an approach and a methodology for investing. If it gets them thinking about their money and financial security as well as their risk tolerance and goals it’s worthwhile.
I wish I would have had this opportunity when I was in high school...or earlier, when I was still really motivated to learn. Perhaps I did ... I'm from PA. Probably just didn't know about it. Anyway, I've learned little bits here and there over the years about investing. My father's famous bit of wisdom was: never touch your principle.
Phoenix: The name of the organization is EconomicsPennsylvania. Website is www.economicspa.org. They have been around since the 70's doing the financial education. There are sister organizations all across the country. Not only do they have the stock market game but also business writing contests, grants, etc.
Honestly, that is the best straight-forward, in-your-face investment advice i have ever heard. Thank you so much for putting it ito terms that professionals and laymen can realte to. I will definitely utilize and pass this on (giving you all the credit, of course)!
Eirerunner it is great to hear that you teach students the value of investing through a stock portfolio game. Please do tell us more about it. The strategy game I mentioned is for young adults and it was done in class while I was still studying a long time ago. I still remember how interesting I found the whole decision making process and the excitement that went with it. So I think it really is an effective teaching method. There was a lot of emotions involved as well since we had to compete with the other teams.
However, I agree with value hiker that investing in the markets with actual money is some what different to the emotions experienced in class. I guess we've grown up and our thinking patterns are also different to what they were while we were in class.
The blogs and comments posted on Investor Uprising do not reflect the views of Investor Uprising, PRNewswire, or its sponsors. Investor Uprising, PRNewswire, and its sponsors do not assume responsibility for any comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.
To save this item to your list of favorite Investor Uprising content so you can find it later in your Profile page, click the "Save It" button next to the item.
If you found this interesting or useful, please use the links to the services below to share it with other readers. You will need a free account with each service to share an item via that service.